Sometimes – not all the time, but sometimes – it takes a lot of energy for me to parse out what people actually mean when they’re talking to me.
For whatever reason, people often don’t say what they mean. They say one thing when they actually mean something else.
[To be clear, this is not some backwards incel notion of “she said no, but actually, I know she meant yes.” Unless y’all have sat down together and explicitly picked a safe word that stands in for the word “no,” that’s generally a really good time to take someone at their word.]
This difficulty with saying one thing when you really mean something else is not a matter of honesty or lies, it’s about directness. I am thinking more and more that directness in communication is more about a sense of safety than anything else.
And, like. I can almost always understand what’s being said to me. I can translate the words that people are saying out loud to what they actually mean. There is nothing wrong with my comprehension skills. Those work fine. This is partly because words aren’t the only way that people communicate, and the thing that most often tells me that more interpretative work needs to be done is the mismatch between body language or tone of voice and the meaning of words.
(i.e., someone saying “I’m fine” when it’s very clear from the way they’re hyperventilating that they are really not fine.)
But sorting through that much, ah – ambiguity is almost the right word here? – I don’t know, this interpretative work takes a certain amount of effort. It takes energy for me. And then, you know – especially when it seems like a person has gone out of their way not to say what they actually mean, burying it like a shameful secret under layers of clues and hints like a game where you’re meant to connect the dots and wake up in a cold sweat at three in the morning when comprehension dawns – what do I do then? Do I nod and smile and wink and respond to the literal meaning of what they’ve just said out loud, just to be safe? Or do I respond to what I can tell they actually mean?
This is not to say that I am always capable of saying exactly what I mean, either. That takes energy, too, plus a sense of safety that traumatized, shell-shocked people like me often struggle to access.
This is also not to say that I’m an infallible interpretation machine. I don’t think anyone is.
I think the kindest thing to do is work towards making a space where speaking directly is a safe thing for everybody. I don’t know for sure how to do that. I’m good at some of them, like listening carefully when people talk without judgement and trying to be respectful of boundaries once I know where they are. I know I’m not perfect.
I just know that having a space where it’s okay and safe to just say what you mean – not just between two people, but also in the world surrounding that connection – is something that helps me and is worth it.